North Carolina still has a cause of action for Alienation of Affections. A person who causes the breakdown of a marriage may be sued in tort by the injured spouse. While typically these lawsuits are filed against the former spouse's paramour, they are not limited to causes solely based on adultery as a cause of the breakdown of the marriage. In order to win such an action, the Plaintiff must show that love and affection existed between the spouses and that the marital relationship was broken by the actions of the Defendant.
Several cases have brought verdicts of over a million dollars. A recent North Carolina case had a $9 million dollar verdict.
Virginia law does not provide for any such remedy.
Wednesday, April 14, 2010
Tuesday, April 13, 2010
Rewriting History
I found an interesting blogpost on The Bitter Divorcée. I haven't read the whole blog, but I enjoyed reading this post.
So often in my domestic violence cases, the batterer simply rewrites history by denying the abuse. Rather than acknowledging the problem and making efforts to change, the abuser points the finger for the abuse at the victim. The victim is alleged to be either lying, crazy, or somehow deserving of the abuse.
Where there has been domestic violence, particularly where there has been serious incidents of violence, it is so important for attorneys to acknowledge and address the client's concerns about safety. Make sure that your attorney is familiar with your history and offers you the tools to address it. Work with your local domestic violence agency to make a safety plan as well.
So often in my domestic violence cases, the batterer simply rewrites history by denying the abuse. Rather than acknowledging the problem and making efforts to change, the abuser points the finger for the abuse at the victim. The victim is alleged to be either lying, crazy, or somehow deserving of the abuse.
Where there has been domestic violence, particularly where there has been serious incidents of violence, it is so important for attorneys to acknowledge and address the client's concerns about safety. Make sure that your attorney is familiar with your history and offers you the tools to address it. Work with your local domestic violence agency to make a safety plan as well.
Monday, April 12, 2010
Child Medical Expenses
Under Virginia law, uncovered medical expenses are typically divided pro rata, in proportion to the parents' income. If you make $4000 a month and your ex makes $2000, you will pay two-thirds of uncovered expenses over $250 per child per year. Many parents make their own arrangements, such as just following a pro rata formula or simply dividing the bills fifty-fifty.
It is imperative for the person seeking reimbursement to keep the bills for which reimbursement is sought. Although it may not be technically required, I advise my clients to provide the receipts to the other parent. It makes sense to deal with these issues in a timely fashion, both on the part of the reimbursing parent and the parent seeking reimbursement. Every year, we have a case where the medical co-pays and other uncovered expenses are sought to be recovered across several years. It creates a problem of proof if those receipts were not kept and are no longer able to be obtained.
It is imperative for the person seeking reimbursement to keep the bills for which reimbursement is sought. Although it may not be technically required, I advise my clients to provide the receipts to the other parent. It makes sense to deal with these issues in a timely fashion, both on the part of the reimbursing parent and the parent seeking reimbursement. Every year, we have a case where the medical co-pays and other uncovered expenses are sought to be recovered across several years. It creates a problem of proof if those receipts were not kept and are no longer able to be obtained.
Friday, April 9, 2010
Putting Your Case on Hold
At least once a month, I hear from a client that she wants to put her case on hold for a while. Sometimes the parties want to consider reconciliation, sometimes one of the spouses needs to delay a divorce in order to continue health insurance coverage, and sometimes the parties just haven't reached the closure they feel they need prior to finalizing.
Cases have their own timing, and each case has subtle nuances. As an attorney, my goal is to help my clients achieve their (legitimate and legal) goals. As a client, your job is to let me know when your goals change, and our goal together is to work toward those goals.
One issue of concern, in Virginia, is that there is a three year rule for divorces. If a divorce has been filed in the Court and is inactive for three years, the Court will dismiss it. Similarly, in North Carolina, the Courts routinely schedule status conferences to move filed cases along. If cases are not resolved, the parties in the case risk the case being dismissed.
If you are not ready to proceed with your divorce, you need to be upfront about that with your attorney. You may decide together that an active divorce case is not your best alternative at that time, and that another form of relief would be better suited for you.
Cases have their own timing, and each case has subtle nuances. As an attorney, my goal is to help my clients achieve their (legitimate and legal) goals. As a client, your job is to let me know when your goals change, and our goal together is to work toward those goals.
One issue of concern, in Virginia, is that there is a three year rule for divorces. If a divorce has been filed in the Court and is inactive for three years, the Court will dismiss it. Similarly, in North Carolina, the Courts routinely schedule status conferences to move filed cases along. If cases are not resolved, the parties in the case risk the case being dismissed.
If you are not ready to proceed with your divorce, you need to be upfront about that with your attorney. You may decide together that an active divorce case is not your best alternative at that time, and that another form of relief would be better suited for you.
Thursday, April 8, 2010
Collaborative Law
We had our local practice group meeting yesterday. The practice group is made of lawyers, financial professionals and mental health professionals who work together on cases to help couples resolve the issues surrounding their divorce in a respectful and cooperative manner. The professionals work with the couple to help them make important decisions about dividing assets and debts, sharing time with their children, and resolving support matters.
Collaborative law involves a completely different mindset than a litigated or settled case. In a litigated case, someone usually wins or loses, but often the "baby is split in half" leaving neither party really satisfied. I am consistently amazed by the creative solutions that families reach in collaboration, when the goal is to honestly discuss the issues, provide all information needed to reach a mutual decision, and to commit that court is not an option for the family. There is no "gotcha" -- the parties and the professionals work as a team, in tandem, rather than with opposing agendas. The agenda -- helping the parties learn communication skills and find their own answers to these often thorny issues -- is one the entire team is seeking.
If you are considering separation or divorce, please see more information on this website.
Collaborative law involves a completely different mindset than a litigated or settled case. In a litigated case, someone usually wins or loses, but often the "baby is split in half" leaving neither party really satisfied. I am consistently amazed by the creative solutions that families reach in collaboration, when the goal is to honestly discuss the issues, provide all information needed to reach a mutual decision, and to commit that court is not an option for the family. There is no "gotcha" -- the parties and the professionals work as a team, in tandem, rather than with opposing agendas. The agenda -- helping the parties learn communication skills and find their own answers to these often thorny issues -- is one the entire team is seeking.
If you are considering separation or divorce, please see more information on this website.
Friday, April 2, 2010
Child Support Guidelines
Child Support, in both North Carolina and Virginia, is typically decided by guidelines. For families with very high incomes, the guidelines may not apply. While judges do not have to follow the guidelines, they often do. If the judge deviates from the guidelines, an explanation of the legal reasoning is usually provided by the judge.
The most important factors for the guidelines are each parent's income, the cost of daycare for a parent to work, and the cost of health insurance for the child. In Virginia, spousal support received is added into the dependent spouse's income and deducted from the payor's income. In NC, alimony paid between the parties to the child support case is not considered.
If the parents have shared custody or split custody, there are alternate formulas to calculate child support.
The most important factors for the guidelines are each parent's income, the cost of daycare for a parent to work, and the cost of health insurance for the child. In Virginia, spousal support received is added into the dependent spouse's income and deducted from the payor's income. In NC, alimony paid between the parties to the child support case is not considered.
If the parents have shared custody or split custody, there are alternate formulas to calculate child support.
Thursday, April 1, 2010
"I Want Half, Eddie..."
Any child of the 1980s has heard Eddie Murphy's monologue about divorce. In it the punchline is about a wife who wants half of the assets at divorce.
In both Virginia and in North Carolina, there is a process called Equitable Distribution, where a judge will figure out a fair division of the couple's property and debts. In North Carolina, there is a rebuttable presumption that the parties will share the assets 50/50, but a litigant can allege and argue that a unequal division would be fairer. In Virginia there is no presumption, and the court looks at a list of factors to determine how to divide the assets fairly.
While it is not always the case that the assets and debts which were acquired during the marriage are divided equally between the parties, it is frequently what happens.
In both Virginia and in North Carolina, there is a process called Equitable Distribution, where a judge will figure out a fair division of the couple's property and debts. In North Carolina, there is a rebuttable presumption that the parties will share the assets 50/50, but a litigant can allege and argue that a unequal division would be fairer. In Virginia there is no presumption, and the court looks at a list of factors to determine how to divide the assets fairly.
While it is not always the case that the assets and debts which were acquired during the marriage are divided equally between the parties, it is frequently what happens.
Labels:
debt,
equitable distribution,
nc,
north carolina,
property,
va,
virginia
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
